Maintain Your True Colors: The Importance of Brand Consistency
Imagine this scenario: you’re at the grocery store, picking up your usual case of soda from a classic brand. But as you inspect the packaging, you notice something odd—some cases are lighter, others darker, and a few even have a slight orange or magenta tint. These color variations deviate from the familiar bright red you expect. Even a small change in color could cause you to question whether the product inside is the same as it always was.
This is the power of brand consistency. Consumers trust certain visual cues, like color, to tell them what to expect from a product. When even the slightest variation appears, it can spark doubt about the product’s quality.
The Role of Consistency in Brand Success
Top brands invest significant effort in maintaining consistency in both their product and marketing. Both aspects play a crucial role in determining a brand’s success. If a product is inconsistent or lacks demand, no amount of marketing will save it. Similarly, without consistent marketing, the demand for the product will eventually fade.
For example, if Coca-Cola® were to stop marketing and switch to generic packaging, it would lose its market share over time. Initially, people might still recognize the product, but gradually, awareness would decline. Without the constant visibility provided by marketing, competitors would take over, and the product would be pushed off the shelves.
Trust Through Consistency
A brand’s strength is built on its ability to deliver what it promises. Consistency in both product and marketing builds trust. If a company claims “same great taste,” customers expect that taste to remain unchanged each time they purchase the product. This is why consistency matters, not only for the product itself but also for the way it’s marketed.
Consistent branding—using the same colors, fonts, and imagery—reinforces the connection between what consumers see and what they expect to experience. Although companies often update their packaging to stay on trend, they typically reassure consumers with a message like “new look, same great taste.” This strategy helps maintain trust by signaling that the product has not changed.
Key Elements of a Brand’s Visual Identity
A brand’s visual identity consists of several elements, including the logo, colors, fonts, and imagery. These elements are carefully outlined in brand guidelines, which marketers and designers follow to ensure consistent branding across all platforms and campaigns.
Maintaining uniformity across these elements is essential for creating a cohesive brand experience. However, many companies face challenges when it comes to one particular aspect—ensuring color consistency across different reproduction methods.

The Challenge of Color Reproduction
While a company can provide press-ready files for print or digital images for web use, there are inherent differences in how colors are reproduced across various mediums. For instance, ink on gloss paper looks different than ink on uncoated paper. Likewise, the same color on a fabric bag will appear differently on a computer monitor.
The difference in appearance is due to the color reproduction methods used. In print, colors are typically produced using either CMYK (cyan, magenta, yellow, and black) or Pantone® spot colors. These methods, along with the substrate (the material the ink is applied to), impact the final color output. On the other hand, colors on computer monitors are reproduced using RGB (red, green, blue), which has a wider color gamut than both CMYK and Pantone®.
Why Color Specifications Matter
To ensure consistency, it’s crucial to not only specify a Pantone® spot color but also to choose one that converts well to CMYK. Since CMYK has the smallest color gamut, specifying a color that works across both Pantone® and CMYK methods helps ensure more accurate reproduction, no matter the medium.
This level of specification is especially important in campaigns like direct mail. Consistent use of logo, tagline, colors, and design style across multiple pieces helps increase brand recognition and message retention.
Strengthening Your Brand Through Consistent Color
By selecting a Pantone® color that translates well across various applications, you can maintain strong brand consistency. But color consistency doesn’t end with color specifications alone. It’s also essential that your vendors—whether they’re designers, printers, or production teams—follow strict processes for color reproduction that meet industry standards.
For instance, Idealliance® certifies commercial printers for their color reproduction capabilities, including grayscale and colorspace accuracy (G7 certification). G7-certified printers are able to reproduce the same color consistently, regardless of the substrate used.
Work with a Certified Printer for Reliable Color Consistency
Phillips Printing is a G7-certified commercial printer, dedicated to helping businesses maintain color consistency across all printed materials. If you have questions about direct mail marketing or print production, feel free to contact us. We’re here to ensure that your brand’s colors stay true and consistent, no matter where they appear.